17 Treasured Local Restaurants in Little Italy, NYC in 2024

You deserve to dine at the top restaurants in Little Italy, NYC. Does Little Italy have good Italian food? Does a bird fly? Yes and yes. Some of the best Italian restaurants in the world are found in Little Italy. This guide explores the best Italian restaurants in Little Italy for families, pizza and amazing experiences. 

Little Italy is a historic spot in Manhattan and has “been shrinking for decades” according to PBS. Rising rents and changing times have moved residents out of the neighborhood. Go while there are still authentic eats around in this historic area. While you’re in the area, check out the nearby rooftop bars in NYC and make sure to take a look at the local vegan restaurants in NYC (if that’s your prerogative). 

Jump to Section

• Best Restaurants in Little Italy, NYC
• Best Family Restaurants in Little Italy, NYC
• Best Pizza in Little Italy, NYC
• Restaurants in Little Italy, NYC FAQs

Best Restaurants in Little Italy, NYC

The best midtown restaurants in NYC can be found in Little Italy. This collection of city blocks is home to some of the top eats in all of Manhattan. 

1. L’Amore Restaurant

L’Amore Restaurant offers a cozy atmosphere with authentic Italian dishes, from handmade pasta to classic tiramisu. Located on the bustling streets of Little Italy, NYC, it’s perfect for a romantic evening or intimate gathering. Enjoy their extensive wine list paired with freshly prepared, flavorful meals that showcase the rich culinary traditions of Italy.

2. Jose Luis Little Italy

Jose Luis Little Italy blends modern culinary techniques with traditional Italian recipes. This standout among restaurants in Little Italy, NYC, features a menu of innovative dishes, including seafood risottos and gourmet pizzas. With a stylish interior and a welcoming vibe, it’s a must-visit for foodies looking for a contemporary take on Italian cuisine.

3. Osteria Barocca

Osteria Barocca captures the heart of Italian dining with rustic charm and refined flavors. Located in Little Italy, NYC, this restaurant delights with specialties like osso buco and truffle-infused pasta. Its warm atmosphere and attentive service make it a favorite spot for indulging in Italy's timeless culinary treasures.

4. Da Nico Ristorante

Da Nico Ristorante is a classic among restaurants in Little Italy, NYC, known for its wood-fired pizzas and hearty pasta dishes. Perfect for casual dining or special occasions, its welcoming ambiance pairs beautifully with the authentic flavors of Italian family recipes passed down through generations.

5. Casa D' Angelo Ristorante

Casa D’ Angelo Ristorante is an elegant dining destination in Little Italy, NYC. Known for its impeccable service and refined menu, it offers everything from fresh seafood to perfectly cooked veal dishes. This upscale eatery provides a sophisticated backdrop for savoring authentic Italian cuisine.

Best Family Restaurants in Little Italy, NYC

Family-friendly restaurants don’t have to be chains. These hidden gems in NYC are perfect for the whole family. Check out the NYC street art with the kids after you’ve finished your fantastic meals. Try to work your way through all the best family restaurants in Little Italy, NYC.

6. Paesano

Paesano stands out as one of the best family-friendly restaurants in Little Italy, NYC. Known for its hearty portions and welcoming vibe, the restaurant serves classic Italian comfort food like spaghetti and meatballs. Its casual atmosphere makes it a hit with kids and adults alike.

7. La Bella Vita - NYC

La Bella Vita offers a delightful experience for families among restaurants in Little Italy, NYC. Featuring a kid-friendly menu and a welcoming ambiance, it serves Italian staples like margherita pizza and chicken parmesan. It’s the perfect spot for a relaxed family dinner.

8. Buona Notte

Buona Notte is a lively option for family-friendly restaurants in Little Italy, NYC. With its spacious dining area and delicious menu featuring pasta and seafood dishes, it caters to all ages. The friendly staff and festive atmosphere ensure a memorable meal for everyone.

9. Grotta Azzurra

A historic eatery, Grotta Azzurra is one of the most iconic family restaurants in Little Italy, NYC. Serving authentic Italian cuisine since 1908, it offers a variety of dishes like risotto and lasagna. The charming ambiance makes it a timeless destination for families.

10. IL Cortile

IL Cortile offers a refined yet family-friendly dining experience among restaurants in Little Italy, NYC. Known for its elegant decor and classic Italian menu, it features dishes like lobster ravioli and chicken piccata. Its cozy private dining rooms are great for family celebrations.

11. Gelso & Grand

Blending modern and traditional, Gelso & Grand is a family-friendly gem among restaurants in Little Italy, NYC. The menu ranges from wood-fired pizzas to inventive pasta dishes. Its lively atmosphere and outdoor seating make it an excellent choice for a casual family meal.

Best Pizza in Little Italy, NYC

These pizza spots make for the best date ideas in NYC. Bring your partner here and chow down on delicious Italian pizza. 

12. Trattoria Taverniti

For classic Italian pizza, Trattoria Taverniti is a top choice among restaurants in Little Italy, NYC. Their thin-crust pizzas, topped with fresh ingredients, capture the essence of traditional Italian cooking. It’s a must-visit spot for pizza lovers.

13. Zia Maria Little Italy

Zia Maria Little Italy offers artisanal pizza with a modern twist among restaurants in Little Italy, NYC. Known for its creative toppings and perfectly crisp crusts, it’s a popular destination for a casual and delicious meal in the heart of the neighborhood.

14. Da Nico Ristorante

Known for its iconic brick-oven pizza, Da Nico Ristorante is a favorite among pizza restaurants in Little Italy, NYC. Their pizzas, made with fresh dough and rich sauces, have been delighting diners for decades. It’s a go-to spot for authentic flavors.

15. Pep’s on Grand

Pep’s on Grand is a hidden treasure among pizza restaurants in Little Italy, NYC. Specializing in classic New York-style slices, Pep’s is perfect for a quick and satisfying meal. Its cozy atmosphere adds to its charm.

16. Rubirosa

A trendy hotspot, Rubirosa is renowned for its thin-crust pizzas among restaurants in Little Italy, NYC. The vodka pizza is a fan favorite, blending rich flavors with a crispy crust. Its modern vibe makes it perfect for both casual and special outings.

17. Sofia’s of Little Italy

Sofia’s of Little Italy stands out for its gourmet pizza offerings among restaurants in Little Italy, NYC. Using premium ingredients, Sofia’s creates mouthwatering combinations like truffle and mushroom or spicy salami. A great spot for pizza connoisseurs.

Restaurants in Little Italy, NYC FAQs

Little Italy, NYC, is a culinary treasure trove brimming with authentic Italian eateries and cool dining experiences. Explore the best food in Little Italy, NYC and these frequently asked questions to discover insider tips and must-visit restaurants.

Is it Worth Going to Little Italy NYC?

Absolutely! Little Italy offers a unique glimpse into New York City's rich Italian-American heritage. Strolling through its charming streets, you’ll find authentic Italian restaurants, quaint cafes and specialty shops that feel like a step back in time. Iconic spots like Ferrara Bakery & Café, known for its decadent cannoli, and Di Palo’s, a beloved cheese shop, provide an unforgettable culinary experience. The best restaurants in Little Italy, NYC will wow you. 

Visiting during the Feast of San Gennaro in September adds extra magic, with lively parades, music and mouth-watering street food celebrating Italian traditions. While the neighborhood has changed over the years, its charm remains undeniable, making it a worthwhile destination for food lovers, history buffs and anyone seeking a slice of Italian culture in the heart of Manhattan. Plus, some of the best places to take pictures in NYC are in or near Little Italy. 

What Is Little Italy, New York Famous For?

Little Italy, a historic Manhattan neighborhood, became a vibrant hub for Italian culture when Italian immigrants settled there in the late 1800s. Today, it’s celebrated for the authentic Italian restaurants in Little Italy, NYC, where cobblestone streets feature eateries serving timeless dishes on red-and-white checkered tablecloths. 

Iconic establishments like Di Palo’s cheese shop and Ferrara Bakery & Café, famous for their cannoli and espresso, remain neighborhood staples. Little Italy also hosts one of New York’s most iconic street fairs, the Feast of San Gennaro, each September. This event honors Naples’ patron saint with festive parades, live music and delectable Italian cuisine, making it a lively tribute to Italian-American heritage.

What Is the Oldest Italian Restaurant in New York?

The oldest restaurants in Little Italy, NYC are delicious but none beat out Barbetta. This slow was established in 1906, is New York City’s oldest Italian restaurant and remains under the ownership of its founding family. Located in the Theatre District, Barbetta is more than just a restaurant—it’s a historic landmark recognized by Locali Storici d’Italia as a “Locale Storico.” 

This distinction highlights its cultural and culinary significance. Founded by Sebastiano Maioglio and later transformed by his daughter, Laura Maioglio, Barbetta revolutionized Italian dining in the U.S. with its elegant presentation of Piemonte cuisine. Barbetta’s combination of history, culinary innovation and timeless elegance makes it a landmark not only in New York’s Italian dining scene but in the city’s cultural fabric.

Little Italy, NYC, remains a timeless destination for food lovers seeking authentic Italian flavors and a unique cultural experience. Each restaurant offers a unique taste of this beloved neighborhood. 

For even more fun things to try in NYC, check out other experiences happening on Classpop!